Aceh Green
By admin at 20 December, 2009, 9:38 pm
Aceh Green
Concept Paper:
Green Economic Development and Investment Strategy for Aceh, Indonesia
“
Aceh Green”
July 2008
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A. Introduction
After Aceh’s historic gubernatorial elections in December 2006 and his inauguration as
the first democratically chosen Governor in February 2007, Irwandi Yusuf has refined his
vision for a comprehensive, holistic strategy to rebuild the economy of Aceh in the
aftermath of the December 2004 tsunami and the three decade-long conflict for
independence.
For Aceh’s reconstruction efforts and the peace process to succeed, the Governor knows
his policies and programs must quickly generate both employment and income
opportunities for all Acehnese, with a particular focus on the poor and ex-combatants. At
the same time, it is critical to ensure the protection and preservation of Aceh’s natural
resources — particularly its extensive inland forests, watersheds and marine reserves —
as key resources for sustainable economic development available for future generations.
The Governor is acutely aware that successful and sustainable post-disaster, post-conflict
recovery requires major new investments and financing from a variety of sources. He is
determined to ensure that investors share and contribute toward his vision.
With the rise of climate change as one of the most imminent threats to the security and
prosperity of the Asia Pacific region, there is a need for an integrated approach to
sustainable development. Particularly with the withdrawal of many aid agencies in April
2009, Aceh will require public-private partnerships, non-governmental oversight, and
private sector involvement to manage clean energy, biofuel feedstock, reforestation and
avoided deforestation, all of which involve issues related to carbon and a commitment to
green development.
In June 2007 Governor Irwandi declared a moratorium on all logging to provide time to
a) review the current status of Aceh’s forests (including forest cover, concessions, and
sustainable production capacity); b) redesign a proper and sustainable forest development
and management strategy (including forestry zoning, policy framework, and institutional
framework); and c) re-enact stronger, more effective enforcement mechanisms to prevent
violations of this policy. The moratorium is sending a message to the international
community that the province is willing to stop deforestation but not without receiving
something in return, i.e., new revenues from trade, not only aid.
To help enforce the moratorium, Governor Irwandi recruited and employed 1,000 forest
rangers / forest facilitators to raise awareness within Aceh’s communities to be more
actively involved in forest protection and implement sustainable forest management. He
will add as many as 2,000 more forest facilitators over the next two years.
Since June 2007, the Governor has initiated a community-based forest management pilot
conducted by local civil society organizations in partnership with the Aceh
administration.
ii
Finally, to elevate the issue of deforestation to a global audience during the recent United
Nations Framework Conference on Climate Change (UNFCCC), Governor Irwandi
signed on 7 December 2007 a joint declaration with the Governors of Amazonas, Brazil,
and Papua and Papua Barat to a) implement policies / programs aimed at promoting
forest conservation and poverty alleviation to reduce emissions from deforestation; b)
share best practices in research and public policies applied to sustainable development,
forest conservation and reduction of deforestation; c) exchange technical and scientific
information; and d) establish mutually beneficial linkages between local communities.
As a result of these actions, the Governor launched his vision — the
Development and Investment Strategy for Aceh, or
Green EconomicAceh Green.
Aceh Green
climate change via renewable energy and land use management, community
development, commerce and conservation. The Governor recognizes that achieving
environmentally sustainable outcomes is only possible with economically sustainable
livelihoods for the people of Aceh, especially the dispossessed and disenfranchised.
will integrate and expand carefully and consciously integrated themes of
Aceh Green
partnerships dealing with infrastructure programs, urban development, clean energy
(including geothermal and hydropower), creation of biofuel feedstock, integrated land use
program in tropical commodities (including, but not limited to coffee, cocoa, palm oil and
rubber), aquaculture and coastal artisinal fisheries, reforestation (rainforest/mangroves)
and avoided deforestation.
will explore establishing an Aceh Green Fund to finance public-private
B. Outline of the Governor’s Vision for Green Economic Development
Aceh Green
1. Land Use, Land Use Change and Forest (LULUCF) Management
Component 1: Primary Forest Protection and Management
Component 2: Reforestation and Forest Restoration
Component 3: Community Forestry and Agro-forestry Development
2. Sustainable Economic Development
Component 4: Smallholder Estate Crop Development in Partnership with Private
Sector and Parastatal Estate Crops & Associated Infrastructure
Component 5: Spatial Planning, Management, and Development of Capture Fisheries
and Aquaculture
Component 6: Public Infrastructure Development
3. Renewable Green Energy
Component 7: Geothermal Energy
Component 8: Micro Hydro
iii
The strategy outlines a five-tiered approach to sustainable land-use management:
1. The Core Zone / Protected Forests: estimated to total approximately 3.1 million
hectares of eternal forests.
2. Restoration Zone / Replanting Protected Forests: estimated at 250,000 hectares
logged-over or secondary forest in higher elevations and steep slopes suitable for
forest restoration through reforestation and assisted natural regeneration, again the
eternal forest.
3. Community-based Production Zone / Community Forests: estimated at 350,000
hectares of mid-elevation, more gently sloping logged-over or secondary forests
suitable for community forestry / agro-forestry schemes.
4. Land Reform / Smallholder Plantation Zone: estimated at 250,000 hectares of largely
level land that fulfills agro-ecological and climatic conditions for smallholder estate
crops like oil palm, rubber, coffee, and coconut with well-established local and global
market demand.
5. Capture fisheries and aquaculture: institutional focus for the development of a “Green
Investment” system for fisheries and other coastal activities, and improvements in the
quality and quantity of post harvest fishery’s products and market access in
cooperation with the private sector.
In addition there are two other land use classifications that are part of the overall Aceh
land situation:
1. Existing Plantation: 200,000 hectares.
2. Existing Agriculture, Aquaculture and Settlements: 1.47 million hectares.
consists of eight main components spread among three priority categories.
A. Introduction
After Aceh’s historic gubernatorial elections in December 2006 and his inauguration as
the first democratically chosen Governor in February 2007, Irwandi Yusuf has refined his
vision for rolling out a comprehensive strategy to rebuild the economy of his province in
the aftermath of the December 2004 tsunami and the three decade-long conflict for
independence. For Aceh’s reconstruction efforts and the peace process to succeed,
Governor Irwandi knows his policies and programs must quickly generate both
employment and income opportunities for all Acehnese, but with a particular focus on excombatants.
The Governor is also determined to protect and preserve Aceh’s natural resources —
particularly its extensive inland forests, watersheds and marine reserves — as key
resources for sustainable economic development available for future generations. He is
acutely aware that successful and sustainable post-disaster, post-conflict recovery
requires major new investments and financing from a variety of sources. However, he is
determined to ensure that investors share and contribute toward his vision.
With the rise of climate change as one of the most imminent threats to the security and
prosperity of the Asia Pacific region, there is a need for an integrated approach to
sustainable development. Particularly with the withdrawal of many aid agencies in April
2009, Aceh will require public-private partnerships, non-governmental oversight, and
private sector involvement to manage clean energy, biofuel feedstock, reforestation and
avoided deforestation, all of which involve issues related to carbon and a commitment to
green development.
This paper outlines the key components that will be required to deliver this vision for the
future of Aceh, provides preliminary projections of the financing and investment
requirements and potential funding sources, and indicates potential revenues over the
next two decades.
B. Origins of the Governor’s Vision for Green Economic Development
To explore new business, technology, and financing partnerships, Governor Irwandi has
led several trade and investment missions to Malaysia, Turkey, India, Europe, China,
South America and the United States. He has called on experts from government,
business, and civil society sectors in Aceh and elsewhere to assist him.
Governor Irwandi also took the bold yet innovative step in declaring a moratorium on all
logging in June 2007. This policy will provide the Governor time to a) review the current
status of Aceh’s forests (including forest cover, concessions, and sustainable production
capacity); b) redesign a proper and sustainable forest development and management
strategy (including forestry zoning, policy framework, and institutional framework); and
c) re-enact stronger, more effective enforcement mechanisms to prevent violations of this
policy.
2
Aceh’s logging moratorium is sending a message to the international community that the
province is willing to stop deforestation but not without receiving something in return,
i.e., new revenues from trade, not only aid, in environmental services and a commitment
from developed countries to continue efforts to reduce their emissions.
To help enforce the moratorium, the Governor recruited and employed 1,000 forest
rangers / forest facilitators to raise awareness within Aceh’s communities to be more
actively involved in forest protection and implement sustainable forest management. He
will add as many as 2,000 more forest facilitators over the next two years.
Since June 2007, Governor has initiated a community-based forest management pilot
conducted by local civil society organizations in partnership with the Aceh administration
to achieve the vision of sustainable forest management while at the same time implement
an assessment of the Aceh timber industry to accurately identify timber demand for
domestic use.
Finally, to elevate the issue of deforestation to a global audience during the recent United
Nations Framework Conference on Climate Change (UNFCCC), Governor Irwandi
signed on 7 December 2007 a joint declaration with the Governors of Amazonas, Brazil,
and Papua and Papua Barat. The objectives are to a) implement policies and programs
aimed at promoting forest conservation and poverty alleviation to reduce emissions from
deforestation; b) share best practices in research and public policies applied to sustainable
development, forest conservation and reduction of deforestation; c) exchange technical
and scientific information on implementation methodologies, verification techniques,
branding and trust mark development, landscape solution developments, investor and
buyer development for forest carbon in foreign markets, risk management techniques,
monitoring and protection strategies, and community benefit sharing and stakeholder
policy development; and d) establish mutually beneficial linkages between local
communities as sustainable forest management practices are rolled out.
As a result of these actions, Governor Irwandi launched his vision — the
Economic Development and Investment Strategy for Aceh (
strategy can be likened to a ‘green” version of the Marshall Plan, which enabled Europe’s
shattered economies to recover after World War II.
capital and will build upon and extend the strong platform already established by
longstanding multi donor funded environmental programs.
GreenAceh Green). TheAceh Green is seeking expansion
Aceh Green
climate change via renewable energy and land use management, community
development, commerce and conservation. The Governor recognizes that achieving
environmentally sustainable outcomes is only possible with economically sustainable
livelihoods for the people of Aceh, especially the dispossessed and disenfranchised.
will integrate and expand carefully and consciously integrated themes of
Aceh Green
partnerships dealing with infrastructure programs (harbor facilities), urban development,
clean energy (geothermal), creation of biofuel feedstock, integrated land use program in
3
tropical commodities (including, but not limited to coffee, cocoa, palm oil and rubber),
aquaculture and coastal artisinal fisheries, reforestation (rainforest/mangroves) and
avoided deforestation.
Since the December 2004 tsunami, subsequent devastation and outpouring of
international aid, a unique coalition between the government and NGOs has committed to
working on the sustainable development of Aceh.
Substantive global awareness and groundwork initiatives related to environmentally
sustainable development have positioned Aceh at the cutting edge of public-private
partnerships, poverty alleviation strategies via sustainable livelihoods and carbon markets
and ecosystem services. Aceh is now in a unique position to capitalize on rapidly
developing carbon finance to succeed in sustainable development.
Two main cornerstones for the Governor’s Green Economic Development and
Investment Strategy for Aceh have been funded and implemented over the last two years
providing a solid investor base to build upon:
1. Aceh Forest and Environment Protection (AFEP), an $18M program funded by
the World Bank’s Multi Donor Fund and administered by Fauna and Flora
International, has successfully mapped extensive land use and conservation
protection opportunities; and
2. Community Climate and Biodiversity Alliance (CCBA) audited Aceh Avoided
Deforestation Voluntary Carbon Program (AADVCP), a multi-million dollar
project funded and administered by Carbon Conservation Pty Ltd., involving
many parties at the forefront of forest carbon markets including SmartWood and
the World Bank.
The innovative nature of
history of failure of piecemeal development strategies where private sector interests often
approach investment with a cut-and-run mentality rather than a managed and sustainable
development plan.
With the evolution of the carbon markets, carbon finance mechanisms are encouraging
comprehensive planning for renewable energy, sustainable land use and forestry. With
rising commodity prices, it is possible to fund sunk costs of developing positive cash
flow agricultural buffer zones on existing deforested land rather than using deforested
timber revenues to forward-fund often unsuccessful cash crops. In anticipation of a post-
Kyoto regime,
will also establish an Aceh Green Fund to finance public-privateAceh Green springs from its pragmatic recognition of the longAceh Green is economically viable and visionary.
Aceh Green
existing public-private partnerships with carbon financing and strong commodity prices
for cash crops and long-term land use planning and infrastructure management. The
Governor believes that success is built upon success and, as such, priority will be given to
initiatives based on a matrix of considerations, including ability for successful execution
and return to investors as well as benefits to community, conservation and climate.
4
C.
is a lower risk proposition as it combines expansion capital to build uponBuilding on a Donor-Driven Economy
The horrific earthquake and tsunami that struck Aceh in December 2004 lead to an
outpouring of international humanitarian aid at levels never before seen. Nearly US$ 8.0
billion was pledged to assist in Aceh’s relief, reconstruction, rehabilitation and recovery.
In August 2005, Aceh was again on the international scene with the historic signing of
the Helsinki Peace Accord that brought peace to Aceh after nearly three decades of civil
conflict.
It is still common to hear the refrain throughout Aceh that there cannot be a sustainable
peace without successful reconstruction and rehabilitation just as there cannot be a
successful recovery without sustained peace. The mandate of the ministerial-level
agency created to manage Aceh’s post-disaster recovery, BRR (the Agency for
Reconstruction of Aceh and Nias), expires in April 2009. Donors working in Aceh,
whether on reconstruction, reintegration or conflict resolution will finish many of their
initiatives at more or less the same time.
Therefore, it is possible a significant level of reconstruction funding will remain unspent
and that the Aceh provincial authorities will need an institutional “gap filler” to assist in
preparing Aceh’s provincial and local authorities to effectively administer and govern in
a donor vacuum environment.
One solution will be to establish effective institutional arrangements to assist during this
transition, such as public-private partnerships between the Aceh provincial administration
(a key and necessary player), donors deciding to remain in Aceh for the long haul, and
qualified non-governmental organizations providing professional technical assistance.
D. Outline of the Governor’s Vision for Green Economic Development
The Governor’s Green Economic Development and Investment Strategy for Aceh
consists of eight main components. Three components fit into the Land use, Land Use
Change and Forest Management category of activities which may be understood as both
an investment sector and physical planning zone. Three components fit into the
commercial-oriented Sustainable Economic Development category of investment
requirements, which also reflect a sector and a physical planning zone. The remaining
two components form part of an innovative, renewable green energy category.
All eight components are designed to generate revenue for the province and employment
for rural communities. The strategy will benefit those in both post-tsunami and postconflict
areas.
Land Use, Land Use Change and Forest (LULUCF) Management
Component 1: Primary Forest Protection and Management
Component 2: Reforestation and Forest Restoration
Component 3: Community Forestry and Agro-forestry Development
5
Sustainable Economic Development
Component 4: Smallholder Estate Crop Development in Partnership with Private
Sector and Parastatal Estate Crops & Associated Infrastructure
Component 5: Spatial planning, management, and development of capture fisheries
and aquaculture
Component 6: Public Infrastructure Development
Renewable Green Energy
Component 7: Geothermal Energy
Component 8: Hydropower
Sectors and Zones in Spatial Terms
In spatial terms, the relationship between elements of the strategy can be described as
concentric circles (see Figure 2). Actual physical planning and zoning will be influenced
primarily by the capacity of different land types to sustainably support different land
uses. But there will also be factors that relate to local, national and global conservation
values; traditional, historical and current land tenure patterns; and physical factors
relating to access and proximity between sites and proposed functions. These together
will mean that on the ground, planning will often not follow the planning ideal of
concentric circles of interrelated zones.
The strategy outlines a five-tiered approach to sustainable land-use management:
1) The Core Zone / Protected Forests: estimated at approximately 3.1 million
hectares of eternal forests.
2) Restoration Zone / Replanting Protected Forests: estimated at 250,000 hectares
logged-over or secondary forest in higher elevations and steep slopes suitable for
forest restoration through reforestation and assisted natural regeneration, again the
eternal forest.
3) Community-based Production Zone / Community Forests: estimated at up to
350,000 hectares of mid-elevation, more gently sloping logged-over or secondary
forests suitable for community forestry / agro-forestry schemes.
4) Land Reform / Smallholder Plantation Zone: estimated at 250,000 hectares of
largely level land that fulfills agro-ecological and climatic conditions for
smallholder estate crops like oil palm, rubber, coffee, and coconut with wellestablished
local and global market demand.
5) Agriculture, coastal capture fisheries, aquaculture and settlements: institutional
focus for the development of a “green investment” system for fisheries and other
coastal activities, and improvements in the quality and quantity of post harvest
fisheries products and market access in cooperation with the private sector.
All five zones consist of lands under the administrative control of the local, provincial or
national governments. The strategy proposes interface with additional estate crop lands
6
either owned by or under management permits held by private individuals, businesses
(PT), or parastatal companies (PTP).
In addition there are two other land use classifications that are part of the overall Aceh
land situation:
1) Existing Plantation: 200,000 hectares.
2) Existing Agriculture and Settlements: 1.47 million hectares.
E. Summary of the Strategy’s Main Components
Component 1: Primary Forest Protection and Management
The protection and management of Aceh’s primary forests and watersheds are essential to
the entire strategy. To protect the more than 1.8 million hectares of natural forest in
Aceh, Governor Irwandi declared on 6 June 2007 a unilateral total moratorium on
logging activities in the province.
A force of 1,000 forest guards has been recruited to monitor and enforce the moratorium.
Protection requires salaries for the guards sufficient to support their families and keep
them highly motivated. The provincial Forestry and Estate Crops/Plantations Department
will need additional funds to provide administrative and technical services and to conduct
forest resource assessments.
Forest protection work will tie in with other forest conservation initiatives currently being
conducted in the Ulu Masen and Leuser Ecosystems and with current and future local and
international organizations and institutions contributing toward the delivery of
conservation objectives in the province.
To help finance primary forest protection and management, Governor Irwandi has
pursued and will continue to pursue development support and commercial arrangements
to assist Aceh province in securing carbon credits for avoided deforestation, afforestation,
and tree planting. Significant revenues from carbon credits could accrue to Aceh over the
next 30 years as a direct result of the strategy’s forest conservation and environmental
restoration policies and practices. Other financing mechanisms, such as Debt for Nature
swaps, will also be promoted.
Component 2: Reforestation and Forest Restoration
The strategy calls for the restoration (and assisted natural regeneration) of degraded and
deforested land throughout the province. The work will create employment for people in
local communities adjacent to these natural forests. To reinforce the peace accord,
communities in active conflict areas will be prioritized.
Seedling nurseries managed by local entrepreneurs and cooperatives will be set up in
several centralized and decentralized locations. This will ensure effective propagation
7
and distribution of appropriate silvicultural species. Local tree planting teams under the
auspices of traditional or civil society organizations (e.g., the Acehnese
kemukiman
village organization system
site preparation, contouring, replanting, and other conservation measures.
Reforestation and restoration will be implemented through a partnership between the
Aceh provincial government, local universities, and local and international NGOs.
Appropriate management and monitoring mechanisms ensuring transparency and
accountability will be established. A rigorous due diligence process will be instituted to
identify the most appropriate institution(s) to undertake this portion of the program.
Funding will be sought from the Australian government’s new US$ 200.0 million
Indonesia-wide reforestation initiative, the World Bank’s pilot carbon facility, and other
possible sources.
Component 3: Community Forestry and Agro-forestry Development
The strategy calls for community-based, multi-purpose tree crop planting involving about
150,000 hectares throughout Aceh province. Tree crop planting will generate initial
employment and long-term income for farmers and laborers in a number of districts
(
diverse permanent tree crops for biofuels, fuel wood, building materials, gums and resins,
and essential oils, as well as fruit trees for immediate consumption and/or sale. Species
could include jatropha, candlenut (
Communities in former conflict areas will be prioritized. Nurseries and tree planting
teams similar to those described in Component 2 will be established in the target areas.
Local community organizations will coordinate planting with cooperatives and individual
families managing the trees thereafter.
These various efforts will be coordinated with existing and future NGO initiatives such as
the Ulu Masen and Leuser Ecosystem Corridor Conservation Program. Specific technical
assistance and training expertise will be sought. Financing for this component -
estimated at US$ 150.0 million – will be sought through carbon trading and multilateral
finance organizations.
Component 4: Smallholder Estate Crop Development in Partnership with Private Sector
and Parastatal Estate Crops and Associated Infrastructure Development
Smallholder estate crop development on land suitable for specific priority commodities is
the fourth major component. The Governor has established a special body called the
Aceh Plantation Development Authority (APDA) modeled after and receiving technical
and managerial support from the Malaysian organization FELDA (Federal Land
Development Agency).
FELDA has more than 45 years experience in organizing smallholder palm oil, rubber,
and cocoa projects. As the largest oil palm producer in Malaysia, it is well versed in
8
agronomic issues, post-harvest processing, and cooperative development. The following
crops will be prioritized:
a) Oil Palm
Development of oil palm plantations is considered to be a central element of plans to
deliver livelihood opportunities for rural communities and economic development of the
province. Oil palm would be developed through smallholder out-grower plantations
working in partnership with private and government plantations. Participating families
would own (e.g., have title to) and achieve secure employment and incomes through the
out-grower plantations.
Currently in Aceh approximately 89,000 hectares are cultivated by smallholder oil palm
producers, 39,000 hectares of government-managed estates (PTP) and 132,000 hectares
in private estates. The total annual production of crude palm oil (CPO) in Aceh from
these lands is currently about 400,000 metric tons. This falls well below the national
average per hectare output. The strategy calls for a substantial increase in smallholder
production combined with anticipated increases in land devoted to private and
government estates.
APDA and the
in strengthening and improving the productivity of the palm oil smallholdings that are
developed as part of the plasma component of private plantations.
The strategy will assure that both existing and new oil palm development in Aceh -
whether government, private, or smallholder – will closely follow the principles and
criteria of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), based in Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia. This global initiative of businesses, government, and civil society is creating
high standards and strong incentives for environmental and social responsibility in the
global palm oil industry. The strategy will stimulate cooperation among the various
stakeholders in Aceh in order to maximize compliance with RSPO and to minimize major
problems with oil palm expansion common in Indonesia and elsewhere. These problems
include forest conversion and land tenure conflicts. If the strategy is instituted, Aceh
will become a model for sustainable palm oil production worldwide.
The smallholder expansion program will be financed in stages, with initial pilot projects
in former conflict areas such as Aceh Jaya/Aceh Barat (Meulaboh), Aceh Utara/Bireuen,
Langsa/Aceh Tamiang and Aceh Selatan/Singkil.
Site selection and planning will be conducted through a participatory landscape-planning
process that combines sophisticated land-use analysis and mapping technologies with
grassroots organizing.
Plantations will be consolidated by local farmer organizations and cooperatives. In turn,
they will have contractual processing and marketing relationships with large estates
attached to crude palm oil (CPO) mills. Participating families will receive land titles,
9
land preparation assistance, optimal seedstock, tools, transition financing and
management support until their plantations reach maturity. The strategy mandates that
smallholders have an effective voice in local pricing boards, along with industry
representatives and state government officials.
b) Coffee
The strategy calls for the rehabilitation of smallholder coffee plantations located in
Aceh’s interior Gayo highlands, specifically the districts of Aceh Tengah and Bener
Meriah. These plantations were abandoned and degraded, and many buildings (mosques,
schools, and homes) in the communities were severely damaged during the last years of
the conflict, from 1998-2005.
After palm oil, coffee is the second-most valuable export commodity in Aceh — and the
best-known one in the international market. Annual production is now about 40,000 tons
and is valued at more than US$ 110.0 million. Aceh’s unique Arabica specialty coffee is
prized by major international buyers such as Starbucks in North America and Europe.
This coffee will be very helpful in establishing Aceh’s post-tsunami / post-conflict
branding and marketing strategy.
Rehabilitation of smallholder coffee could assist more than 12,000 families to recover
their livelihoods and increase total production by about 15,000 tons.
In addition to rehabilitation of existing areas and replanting of new coffee trees, the
strategy establishes post-harvest processing and marketing infrastructure and calls for the
creation and strengthening of farmer organizations and cooperatives.
The strategy also increases certification and marketing via specialty channels such as
organic and Fair Trade. Higher prices and greater incomes for farmers will result.
c) Other Estate Crops
The Governor’s strategy proposes to establish smallholder plantations in other estate
crops, especially rubber, cocoa, and nutmeg. This effort, similar to the coffee program
above, includes new plantings through nursery establishment, modest post-harvest
processing managed by farmers themselves, cooperative formation, and certification.
Two programs supported by the German agency GTZ in the districts of Pidie and Bireuen
in the northern part of Aceh covering 4,000 hectares will serve as a pilot project for these
crops. Additional proposals will be formulated by NGOs and/or the private sector and
presented to the BRR and other bilateral funders.
Private and parastatal companies with proven track records in Aceh and other parts of
Indonesia will provide the needed capital, infrastructure, expertise, and market access for
the new and existing smallholders. The private sector in Aceh, in Indonesia and
internationally will be invited to make substantial equity and debt investments toward the
rehabilitation of existing, and the setup of new, large-scale plantations and processing
10
plants, primarily for oil palm. The private sector and NGOs will also be encouraged to
provide training and technical support to smallholders in such areas as Good Agricultural
Practices (GAP), worker health and safety, quality control, and financial management.
The strategy anticipates new oil palm plantings by private companies in several coastal
districts of Aceh within the next three-five years. These companies will also establish
new large-scale CPO mills and create significant expansion of storage tanks and
distribution facilities. Within five years, one or more palm oil refineries will also be
established for value-added palm and palm kernel oil products. Investment of US$ 1.0
billion by private companies and banks can create a minimum of 30,000 full time jobs
over the next 10 years. The strategy provides for special incentives and regulations to
support private sector compliance with sustainability principles and practices, such as the
RSPO, and fair labor and wage standards.
Biofuels development: The strategy encourages the private sector in developing a
biofuels industry in Aceh. Biofuels would be based initially on palm oil and branch out
to include other products such as jatropha, sago palm, and sugarcane. The strategy sets
up a framework for Aceh’s biofuels industry based on avoided deforestation, carbon
credits, and strict sustainability standards. This will serve to distinguish Aceh from other
parts of Indonesia and regions of the world and boost investor and consumer confidence
in the province. The overall strategy for Sustainable Biofuels in Aceh – including
financing, investments, infrastructure, and business development – will be developed
within the next year.
During the Governor’s trip to the U.S. in September 2007, two of the largest biodiesel
producers expressed solid commitments in sourcing verified and/or certified sustainable
palm oil from Aceh. These companies expressed strong interest in partnering with
Indonesian and Malaysian companies to secure long-term product sourcing needs. This
might include co-investment in existing and new plantations, supporting biofuel
technology transfer, and underwriting long-term off take (supply) agreements. With the
likely conversion of most of the liquid fuels in Hawaii to biofuels by 2010, the market
needs for sustainable palm oil in the U.S. will rise substantially. The EU’s mandate to
increase biofuel content of overall engine fuels to 10% by 2020 and consumer preference
for sustainable sourcing can help create a strong market opportunity for Aceh.
Component 5: Spatial Planning, Management, and Development of Capture Fisheries and
Aquaculture
At least 21% of the total population in Aceh (810,000 of a total of 4 million) depends on
the fisheries sector – as either fishermen, fish pond cultivators, traders, manufacturers,
service providers, collectors and others – for their livelihoods. Currently there is an
urgent need for greater attention to be concentrated on the fisheries sector to help
facilitate livelihood rehabilitation and economic development. However, meeting this
need will likely create changes in exploitation levels of fishery resources and changes in
how marine and coastal ecosystems are used. It is therefore important that a
11
comprehensive process of sustainable management planning and policy formation
accompany the development of the fisheries sector.
a) Coastal, Marine, and Fisheries Resources Conservation
Environmental conditions for Aceh coastal and marine resources have been under
pressure because current rehabilitation activities have not adequately considered
environmental impacts. This situation could lead to ecological imbalance, biological
extinction, and reduced biodiversity, which will affect fisheries livelihoods.
There is a need for a community-based management model. This model is believed to be
more efficient, effective, and strongly accepted by the public, which will lead to
successful implementation. Local wisdom that is implemented as traditional law
(“hukum adat laot”) should become the basis for this management model. Governmental
policies will need to be integrated with traditional “hukum adat laot”, with more
emphasis on efforts to care for, save, and protect marine and fisheries resources.
b) Fisheries Products
Post harvest handling and processing of fisheries products in Aceh are not optimal, which
causes a loss in quality, economic value, and market access opportunities. An increase in
productivity must be supported with good post harvest handling along the supply-chain to
sustain quality and increase product value in the market.
In order to increase marine and fisheries contribution to Aceh public welfare and
economic development, there is a need to promote fisheries products for marketing and
distribution network expansion. There is also a need to empower public institutions, such
as co-ops, to accommodate collection and distribution. Additionally, there is a need for
processing and transportation infrastructure establishment, rehabilitation, and
improvement that accelerate distribution for quality preservation. All of these initiatives
must consider prioritization as well as unique characteristics of each area. There is also a
need for an easily accessible integrated fisheries information system. Additionally,
capacity building for any entities, which are involved in fisheries activities, must be
strengthened to improve handling, processing, management, and diversification of
fisheries products. All of these efforts are necessary to increase public revenue from
fisheries activities.
c) Fair and Sustainable Policy on Resource Management: A Green Fisheries Investment
System
Current problems in the fisheries sector appear because of policy, authority or
institutional shortfalls – including, insufficient extension services for fishermen, conflict
among fishermen, overlapping of exploitation licenses in coastal and marine areas, and a
lack of spatial planning for aquaculture activities. There are also problems related to the
unclear division between coastal and marine management authorities, no clear rules in
regards to the amount, or allocation, of mangroves that can be converted or developed
into
government level, and inter-autonomy areas). There is also no institutional system to
accommodate co-management among the government and other important parties and,
just as important, there is no financial institution that can lend necessary capital.
There is an urgent need for the Aceh government to develop a Green Investment System
as a base policy for any activities related to investments, infrastructure, and
developments, which will be conducted on, or will impact, the marine, coastal, and
fisheries resources. There is also a need to develop a compensation strategy or
accreditation as ordered in UU no 27 2007 on coastal areas and small islands
management. This accreditation will be applied to anyone who will utilize coastal and
marine areas for developments or investments as a mean of responsible conduct. This
strategy will ensure sustainable management of marine, coastal, and fisheries resources.
Component 6: Public Infrastructure Development
This component involves government programs and investments for significantly
improving Aceh’s infrastructure – specifically communications, transportation, and
logistics. Such investments will be critical in boosting the competitiveness,
attractiveness, and security of Aceh as a whole. Clearly, infrastructure development will
cross between and establish linkages between the various development / planning zones.
An estimated minimum of US$ 525.0 million in credits, low interest loans, and partial
grants is required to successfully launch this part of the strategy. This would include
upgrading and expansion of major port facilities, setup of feeder ports and CPO
terminals, and building of specific connective roads. On the communications side, it
entails targeted improvements in communications infrastructure (i.e., satellite, wire, and
cable) and power generation facilities.
Perhaps more important than the physical improvements, the Aceh government needs to
create an educated and properly motivated workforce that abides by international
standards of integrity and accountability to the fullest extent. This requires extensive
, religious groups, or NGOs) will be contracted to carry outkabupaten). Community forestry and agro-forestry will promote intercropping ofkemiri), betel palm (pinang), and dammar.Dinas Kehutanan dan Perkebunan (Dishutbun) will play important rolestambak, and there are conflicts in exploration (conflict among inter-sector, inter12insitu
and overseas training of Acehnese students in the coming years.
Several of the needed improvements and investments already exist on paper (if not in
practice) under other program auspices. Accordingly, the strategy needs to be reviewed
and coordinated with other organizations and initiatives such as BRR, the World Bank,
the Asia Development Bank, USAID, AusAID, and other bilateral donors. Once this
review process has been completed, the provincial and local governments of Aceh can
finalize the remaining infrastructure investments in critical areas of the province.
Component 7: Geothermal Energy
There are large opportunities for geothermal energy in Aceh including the proposed 180
MW station with provisional support from a German government research fund. It is the
intention to assist Aceh assess and develop feasibility studies of geothermal energy,
which would power Aceh and provide for export of power to Sumatra.
13
Energy projects including renewable green energy will be the jurisdiction of the
Provincial Government and not the Central Government based on new autonomy law for
Aceh (Law No. 11/2006 on the Governing of Aceh).
Component 8: Hydropower
Given the number of watersheds and rivers in the contiguous forests of Aceh, there are a
number of hydropower opportunities. Since the 2004 tsunami, dozens of functioning
microhydro electricity facilities are already in operation.
F. Aceh’s Global Leadership in LULUCF and Carbon Markets
Global attention is focused on the inclusion of Reduced Emissions from Deforestation
and Degradation (REDD) into Kyoto or post-Kyoto carbon markets. REDD fits within
the wider component of Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry (LULUCF). LULUCF
constitutes 18-25% and is the 2
fired power (IPCC 2007). With LULUCF emissions 85% of Indonesia’s national
emissions total, when included, the country rises from 21
China and the USA (World Bank 2007). Reducing these emissions from land use and
deforestation could represent revenues of $5-10 billion per annum (Stern 2007).
Working with Carbon Conservation and Fauna and Flora International, the Governor of
Aceh put in motion plans for a moratorium on deforestation (all logging) on 26 April
2007 with the historic signing of a 3 Green Governors Declaration at Bali in anticipation
of the Kyoto COP 13 event. To facilitate carbon financing, Aceh’s Governor was a
global pioneer, and with Carbon Conservation, Fauna and Flora International and
SmartWood (Rainforest Alliance) have been working with the donor community and the
private sector to consummate a significant carbon transaction.
Carbon Conservation, with the intention to develop a strong community, climate and
biodiversity platform for all projects, assisted in developing an initial project design
document (PDD) for the 750,000 Ha of the cross jurisdiction forested area of Ulu Masen.
The project will use carbon finance to conserve forestland in one of the last unprotected
tracts of tropical forest on the island of Sumatra.
Deforestation will be reduced by 85 percent over 30 years and thereby avoid the emission
of more than 3.3 million tons of carbon dioxide annually. Local residents will benefit by
receiving financial incentives to protect their resources and develop alternative
livelihoods using income from carbon sales. In addition, the project will support
increased forest monitoring, provide funding to civil society organizations to monitor
project activities, and support the restoration and reforestation of mangroves, fruit tree
gardens, coffee plantations and woodlots.
This provides the platform for a strong ethical and green credential for all projects and
developments on the adjacent and surrounding land.
14
nd biggest category of global annual emissions behind coalst to 3rd biggest emitter behind
Figure 1
15
Figure 2
Aceh Green Vision
Existing
Forest 3,101,960
Degraded land 804,550
Plantation 209,703
Agriculture/coastal settlements/
urban
1,504,112
Total 5,620,325
1. Eternal Forest (existing) 3,101,960
2. Eternal Forest
(replanting)
250,000
3. Community forestry Up to 350,000
4. Land Reform
(Smallholder Plantation)
250,000
5. Existing Plantation 200,000
5. Agriculture/ coastal
settlements & other use
1,468,000
Total ± 5,619,960
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
- Pingback by Aceh Green | The real marketing club on December 21, 2009 @ 2:43 am










I found your site on technorati and read a few of your other posts. Keep up the good work. I just added your RSS feed to my Google News Reader. Looking forward to reading more from you down the road!
I found your blog on MSN Search. Nice writing. I will check back to read more.
Eric Hundin
I finally decided to write a comment on your blog. I just wanted to say good job. I really enjoy reading your posts.
With some of the new green technologies now available it is easy to generate power with renewable energy.
I have just started a Green energy company to help smaller communites get cheap electricity and clean drinking water.
I think you are right. But you should cover more on this topic.
I read a few topics. I respect your work and added blog to favorites.